Judge\

Decision of the federal judges to police officers Arizona requires entry clearance in the country are suspected to prevent illegal had an enormous victory Obama administration and civil society, the rights groups, the change may be difficult, at least in the short term.

USA United States District Judge Susan Bolton Phoenix prevent an order enforcement of Arizona, the heart of the new Aliens Act on Wednesday issued at least 24 hours before the power and the government\'s argument that the government can one state recognized to affect the Federal Network Agency\'s immigration service.

The key provision of the law by local police for confirmation of legal residence for people who ask to be closed for other reasons, and suspect that it is illegal. Prisoners were held in detention until their status is determined.

\"The federal government recently refused a system of foreign documents to be reviewed on a regular basis and application, the judge said, citing Justice Department attorneys.

Let implement the system, he said, would \"unfair burden\" may not lawfully in the file.

There are many reasons they are illegal immigrants, and thus risking prison terms of up to secure the position, \"said Bolton. They may be asylum seekers szuka za shelter victims of domestic violence, the role of the police also arrested for offenses like Jaywalking.
Blocked the main provisions of the

Your application for state enforcement of penalties for non-citizens, to prevent illegal immigrants and criminal penalties for illegal immigrants looking for work. Bolton said that to punish federal and state law, only the beginning, the employer knowingly illegal immigrants. U.S. Supreme Court is required to determine the appropriateness of the sanctions against employers in Arizona.

Bolton is a relatively small force of today, including tougher penalties for traffic, transport and reception of illegal immigrants.

January, the governor has said Brewer, that to fight the decision by the United States quickly Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco. He was told that the bill SB1070, it was necessary, \"has created the crisis in the federal government much, and participated actively to solve the problem.\"

Bolton said that concerns about the decision.

Arizona has the \"context of rampant illegal immigration, increasing crime and drug trafficking, and serious public safety,\" said the judge. The state has a legitimate interest in illegal immigration and said the problems but I can not change federal policy.

The court \"cry for a Board\" said lawyer Richard Samp Washington Legal basis, making the Arizona legislature.
Stay unlikely

But legal analysts said, other that, if the decision of the Court of Appeal in Bolton and the law takes effect immediately questioned. This will require appellate court judges noted that Bolton has committed a clear error of law, and the conclusion at this stage is unlikely, \"Carl Tobias, law professor at the University of Richmond said.

Although the Court of Appeal and the Supreme Court may finally leave Bolton, judges often gave the judge the right decision after hearing both sides, \"Vikram Amar, Professor of Law said at the University of California, Davis. If returning this by no means the case, the final decision to Bolton and then a year or consider a change.

Bill Hing, said one other law professor at the University of California, Davis, stresses that the Department of Justice Civil Rights Division - under the leadership of Tony West, a former district attorney in Oakland - put forward the argument that \"the creative experience in government, to set priorities for immigration control and is based on the Supreme Court decision in 1941 based.

This decision, Bolton repeatedly stated his decision to hit a Pennsylvania law requires that all non-citizens to register annually, show that the identification document can ask the police to see. The judge said that the failure of federal registration, and more flexible under the general powers of government to meet the immigration.
Federal Regulations

Obama Administration, which moved to a conservative approach to immigration, Arizona, tried to strike a conciliatory tone Wednesday.

\"While I understand the frustration of the citizens of Arizona immigration system, the mosaic of local and national policy, a serious federal immigration law,\" said Justice spokeswoman Hannah August.

City of San Francisco also in the legal battle, with other local authorities that the Arizona law, if after the other, they could hamper efforts to combat crime, to prevent people from cooperating with the authorities.

Gascn Police Chief George, who was in the same location on the outskirts of Phoenix, Mesa, warned in April that the law \"a drop of the police for decades. \"

Civil rights groups had filed the appeal, arguing that the right result for split Arizona racial discrimination, the problem is that Bolton has not been debated Wednesday .

Judge\

ความคิดเห็น